Good thing there was some lead time and I had a trip to NYC planned so I pick up and sample the cheese from Murrays in GCT and pair them with some wine. Experimenting was the fun part! One thing I learned about is the aging of Mimolette Cheese and you have to have the correct aging to go with the Malbec. Mimolette aged 6 months is a lot creamier than when aged for 22 months. As you can see from the above photo, I chose the 22 month old (orange cheese)
Many cheese produced in Europe are governed by similar AOC rules as wine. In fact Comte St. Antione cheese must pass an evaluation of 12 or more point out of 20 to be able to put Comte St. Antione on the label. If you purchase the cheese and it's more yellow it is because it was produced in the summer from cows dining a pasture rich in carotene.
Also right here in the Hudson Valley, Old Chatham Sheepherding Company has over 1000 East Friesian purebred and cross bred ewes. This makes them the largest sheep dairy farm in the United States.
Here were the pairings:
Le Colture Fagher Valdobbiadene D.O.C.G. Prosecco - Bright lemon and green apple notes with a hint of breadiness.
Pairing: Old Chatham Sheepherding Hudson Valley Camembert
Trumpeter 2011 Chardonnay- Aromas of rich tropical fruit lead into flavors of citrus fruits followed by a refreshingly crisp finish with hints of vanilla.
Pairing: Comté St Antione
2011 Dr. Loosen Erdener Treppchen Riesling Kabinett- Subtle and pure notes of cassis, slate, white orchard fruits as well as a touch of passion fruit.
Pairing: Epoisses De Bourgogne
2008 Clos La Coutale- Smoky berry aromas., dark cherry, plum. Dark fruit, black currants, leading to a smooth plum vanilla finish.
Pairing: Mimolette Cheese
2006 Finca Loranque - Syrah/Tempranillo - Aromas of black fruit , the palate dances with blackberry and raspberry. As the wine opens up plum and dart fruit enter. Finish with soft spice.
Pairing: Manchego Cheese
Taylor Fladgate 2005 Late Bottle Vintage- Fresh intense blackcurrant & cherry aromas with subtle notes of liquorice, spice and raisin. Palate is rich and concentrated black fruit with firm well integrated tannins.
Pairing: Stilton Blue Cheese
I think the two winning wines of the afternoon (if I had to pick from the comments and re-pours) were the 2011 Trumpeter Chardonnay and the 2006 Finca Loranque Syrah/Tempranillo.
I want to thank the Mid Hudson Food & Wine Society for a wonderful afternoon!